Help with Saltwater Minnow ID

4 posts / 0 new
Last post
Dima
Help with Saltwater Minnow ID

Hello evryone,

could you please help me identify these species?

They all been caught around New York City:

1. Possibly the striped killifish (Fundulus majalis), also called the striped mummichog (male and female):

 

2. Possibly the banded killifish (Fundulus diaphanus):

 

 

3. No idea:

Bitterling
Bitterling's picture
Striped Killifish and Mummichogs

The top pics are Striped Killifish, the other three are Mummichog I think

uconn fishhead
uconn fishhead's picture
Agree

Agree with Bitterling

Dima
I see, #2 is definitely not

I see, #2 is definitely not banded killifish, and look very like mummichogs. Striped killifish pattern is so different on every specimen, so I wasn't sure - thank you for the confirmation.