I am 99% sure that this is a River Carpsucker. It had a nipple on its lip, its dorsal fin was short (not broken as far as I could see), and it had a much skinnier body than the quillback I've seen before. Caught on a small nightcrawler while fishing for redhorse in a deeper hole. Side note: I have completed my 2017 goal of catching all 3 carpsuckers (all blind-fished too)! This is definitely one of my favorite catches.